The Five Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce

PIZZA! Just the thought of having a perfectly baked pizza topped with your favorite sauce and cheese makes your mouth water. It is undeniable that even hearing the term pizza can trigger your appetite. Pizza has been the favorite dish and the go-to comfort food of many in the world for years.

Whether you crave a restaurant-baked pizza or decide to make your pizza at home, what matters the most is having your pizza topped with the best pizza sauce.

With the store-made pizza sauce available in the market today, pizza making has been easier than ever. As there are multiple options in stores, finding the best pizza sauce that appeals to your palate is not a simple task. Hence, we prepared this guide featuring the five best store-bought pizza sauces available in the food market today.

The Top Five Store-Bought Pizza Sauce

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce, 14.5 Ounce (Pack of 12) – A Great Choice for Health-Conscious Pizza Lovers B00F9TCLAY

Don Pepino Pizza Sauce, one of America’s oldest and finest pizza sauces created from fresh tomatoes, has been satisfying the palate of millions of people since 1950.  

The main ingredient in Don Pepino is fresh tomatoes which are plucked from vines after they have ripened to the maximum. This best-tasting sauce also contains cholesterol-free corn oil, salt, garlic, and other spices. Well-ripened tomatoes combined with aromatic spices and herbs are blended into a rich texture gifting pizza lovers the most luscious taste. 

Unlike other pizza sauces available in the market, Don Pepino is free from additives such as paste, purees, preservatives, starches, gums, sugar, artificial color, citric acid, or fillers. Because of its healthy recipe, the sauce has secured the trust of many households. In addition to pizza, this store-bought sauce can also be an alternative when cooking other dishes, such as meat, spaghetti, and pasta. 

As there are 12 cans of pizza sauce, each weighing 14.5 ounces in one pack, Don Pepino would be the best store-bought pizza sauce for the users who are interested in storing sauce for long periods and trying out many different sauce-based recipes.

Pros Cons
A family recipe cherished for more than seven decades.
Made out of fresh tomatoes
Cholesterol free
Dairy-free – Great choice for those who are allergic to dairy
Free from preservatives and other artificial additives
Not too spicy – Great for children
You might have to add extra spices to make the pizza taste spicier.
May contain a few tomato seeds in the sauce.

See Price on Amazon

If you are looking for a cholesterol-free, yet succulent pizza sauce, this would be your go-to option!

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce, 15 Ounce Can (Pack of 12) – The Best Organic Store-bought Pizza Sauce B000LKZ9JG

Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce is served using fresh and organic tomatoes grown in America’s primary tomato growing region—San Joaquin Valley of California. This best store-bought pizza sauce is known for its rich tomato flavor. 

Well-ripened tomatoes harvested at their peak are cooked down into a thick and flavourful sauce with organic extra virgin olive oil and deliciously seasoned with sea salt, onion, oregano, basil, black pepper, and garlic. 

The sauce is smooth with no seeds or chunks of tomato in it. In addition to pizza, you can use it to intensify the flavor of other tomato sauce-based dishes such as pasta and spaghetti. 

Established a decade ago, Muir Glen is an environmentally friendly business named after the naturalist John Muir. It not only provides a source of income for thousands of farmers in the States but also assures a healthy and chemical-free pizza sauce for buyers. 

Not only that, Muir Glen’s massive composting program converts waste generated from the sauce-making process into soil rich in nutrients that would, in turn, be useful for independent organic farmers. 

This best store-bought pizza sauce comes in a 12 can package, each can weighing 15 ounces.

Pros Cons
Made out of organically grown fresh tomatoes.No added synthetic chemicals
Smooth with no seeds or chunks of tomato in it
No added sugar
Thick texture
Seasoned with Italian herbs and spices giving the sauce a nice aroma and flavor
Low sodium content
Those who find the sauce a bit bland and traditional might have to be innovative in adding your
own ingredients to make the pizza sauce spicier

Must be stored in the fridge once opened

Some might find that it has a sour taste to it

See Price on Amazon

Buy Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce to save your precious time consumed to prepare pizza sauce at home!

Godfather’s Pizza Sauce – The Best Restaurant Style Pizza Sauce B0716DP3PK

With a history of more than four decades, Godfather’s is the best store-bought pizza sauce for those who crave restaurant-style pizza sauce. Unlike other canned pizza sauces available in the market, Godfather’s pizza sauce comes in a perfectly sealed glass bottle and guarantees you the freshness of natural tomatoes once you open it. 

You will be fascinated by the exquisite taste of this all-natural store-bought pizza sauce deliciously seasoned with a combination of herbs and spices such as salt, oregano, basil, onion, citric acid, and garlic powder. 

Godfather’s Pizza sauce is also the secret ingredient behind America’s all-time favorite Godfather’s pizza.  

In addition to pizza, Godfather’s pizza sauce is used to flavor many Italian dishes and used as a dipping sauce for dishes like pizza pinwheels, calzones, and breadsticks. 

But heat it first before using it as a dipping sauce. Godfather’s Pizza Sauce has been the favorite store-bought pizza sauce of many pizza lovers, mainly because it’s free from any added sugar.

Unfortunately, this product is currently unavailable on Amazon. But if you can find it somewhere else, its a worth look-see.

Pros Cons
Made using fresh tomatoes
Stored in a glass container
Cholesterol free
Should be stored in the refrigerator once opened

Some users may find the pizza sauce
not as good as the original pizza sauce
they have tried in Godfather’s pizza outlets.

See Price on Amazon

If you seek to have restaurant experience in homemade pizza, Godfather’s restaurant-style pizza sauce is the best option for you! 

Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef, Original, 8-Ounce (Pack of 12) – The Best Italian Store-Bought Pizza Sauce for Health-Conscious Consumers B001SAQDYS

Founded in 1952 in Italy, the magnificent recipe of Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef has been a family heirloom for more than six decades and has been enjoyed and admired by many since then. If you want to experience the authentic Italian taste in pizza, this would be the perfect store-made pizza sauce. 

While the main ingredient is fresh vine-ripened San Marzano-style tomatoes, the other additives such as imported extra virgin olive oil, canola oil, salt, imported Pecorino Romano cheese, garlic, Italian spices, and herbs, and citric acid give this best store-bought pizza sauce a rich and zesty flavor. The smooth texture and the perfect balance of aromatic spices and herbs make the Pastorelli Pizza Sauce exceptionally good.

The sauce is used not only as a pizza topping but also for other Italian dishes like pasta and spaghetti and also sandwiches. Unlike other store-made pizza sauces, the best feature of Pastorelli Pizza Sauce Italian Chef is that it doesn’t contain harmful preservatives, corn syrup, and gluten. The sauce is packaged in a BPA-free can.

Unfortunately, this product is currently unavailable on Amazon. But if you can find it somewhere else, its a worth look-see.

Pros Cons
Has a strong tomato flavor
No added preservatives
Corn syrup free
Cholesterol free
Comes in a BPA free can
Imported Pecorino Romano cheese enhances the flavor of the pizza sauce
If you want a sweet sauce, this is not the option for you
Some consumers may find that the sauce has a tangy taste
Might be allergic to lactose-intolerant people because this contains cheese

See Price on Amazon

If you want to experience the authentic Italian flavors, Pastorelli Italian Chef Pizza Sauce is the best store-bought pizza sauce for you!

Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce, All Natural, 13 oz – The Irresistibly Flavourful Store-Bought Pizza Sauce B00L26YPLQ

Started in 1896 as a family business, Rao’s is renowned for its delicious and authentic Italian sauce recipes. Rao’s All Natural Homemade Pizza Sauce is an exceptional pizza sauce made out of all-natural ingredients. The combination of sun-ripened Italian plum tomatoes and sweet cherry tomatoes hand-picked from the farms in Southern Italy adds an exquisite taste, which is a rare find in other pizza sauces available in the market. Another distinctive ingredient you can find in Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce is carrots. 

You may find it unusual, but carrots leave you with that fruity sweetness and help to maintain the balance of tastes among different elements used in the sauce. The sauce is slowly simmered in Italian olive oil with a combination of other ingredients such as salt, onions, basil, garlic, and oregano, giving it a true Italian flavor. 

The sauce is good and healthy as a homemade pizza sauce. Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce contains no gluten, no cholesterol, no added sugar, and no artificial preservatives and colors, and high saturated fat. Likewise, a good source of vitamins A and C.

In addition to being used as a delicious pizza topping, Rao’s sauce can also be used to add more flavor to your delicious homemade dishes; pasta, meat, fish and seafood, salads, and other vegetarian dishes.

Unfortunately, this product is currently unavailable on Amazon. But if you can find it somewhere else, its a worth look-see.

Pros Cons
A low carb pizza sauce, therefore ideal for people with dietary restrictions
Made with all-natural ingredients
Comes in a reusable glass jar
Abalone free
Should be refrigerated once opened

See Price on Amazon

Choose the nutritious and delicious Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce for a magical experience!

Choosing the Best Store-Made Pizza Sauce to Buy

Pizza is a favorite by people from every nook and corner of the world. It is hardly possible to find a major city in any country without a pizza place in it. When talking about the ingredients in a pizza, pizza sauce is essential. 

You would agree with me if I told pizza without a pizza sauce cannot be recognized as a pizza. Making pizza sauce at home is a time-consuming task. With the different varieties of pizza sauce available in the stores today, pizza making at home has become an easier task.

We may have our preferences when deciding to buy a store-made pizza sauce. Yet, there are many factors to be considered when purchasing a pizza sauce for your homemade pizza. Thus, we prepared this buying guide to help you select the best-tasting store-made pizza sauce high on nutritional value. 

Factors to Consider when Buying the Best Store Made Pizza Sauce


Many people are very concerned about the ingredients of a pizza sauce. While many store-bought pizza sauce recipes are tomato-based, pizza sauce may differ to flavor the sauce. Most pizza sauces being true to their Italian origin, contain Italian herbs and spices. Pizza sauce with fresh basil in it is adored by pizza lovers from all over the world.

Another important factor when it comes to ingredients is checking whether the pizza sauce you are going to buy contains any elements that are allergic to you. Some pizza sauces may contain dairy components like cheese that are allergic to some people. Therefore you have to know the ingredients well before using any kind of pizza sauce.

Users should also be thoroughly aware of the nutritional value of the pizza sauce they are going to purchase. People on keto diets and with dietary restrictions may find a sauce with no sugar, no gluten, no cholesterol, low sodium level, and high on vitamins appealing. Before buying canned pizza sauce, you should always check the label.

Pizza style

Before choosing the best pizza sauce to buy, you have to match the pizza sauce with the other ingredients you are going to top the pizza with. The sauce should be carefully chosen in a way that it helps to enhance the flavor of the other ingredients in the pizza. 

Different types of sauce will go with different crusts. For instance, it is not good to top a thin crust pizza with a diluted sauce, because it will make the bread soggy. 

Ability to be innovative with the sauce

When looking for a store-made pizza sauce to buy, make sure that it doesn’t limit you to a certain set frame. As pizza lovers, you should be allowed to think creatively and try out new recipes by experimenting with the pizza sauce you have bought.

You can enhance the flavor of the pizza sauce by adding a variety of herbs and spices.

Other than making pizza, pizza sauce can also be used to make many other dishes and to dip many kinds of food.


Before buying a pre-prepared pizza sauce make sure you check how it is packaged. The priority should be given to reusable glass jars and BDP free cans. We would recommend the glass jars because it is good for both the environment and your health.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there a difference between pizza sauce and pasta sauce?

Yes. Pizza sauce is an uncooked variety of tomato sauce whereas pasta sauce is cooked by simmering. Pizza sauce consists of simple tomato puree seasoned with salt, pepper, garlic and other Italian herbs and spices. But, pasta sauce is spiced up more using more herbs. There are more vegetable chunks in pasta sauce than in pizza sauce, therefore, the former is thicker in texture. 

What is the best packaging method? Jar or Can?

The jar is better than can because it is reusable, environmentally friendly and also a healthy option.

What is the texture of the sauce I should go for? Smooth or Thick?

That depends on your preference and the type of pizza you are making. If you prefer to have vegetable and tomato chunks in your store-bought sauce, go for the thick texture, otherwise, choose a sauce with a smooth texture.

Where can I buy pizza sauce?

You can go online to choose from a wide range of pizza sauces. Also, pizza sauce is available in large supermarkets and grocery stores.

What is the better flavor? Spicy or Mild?

Go for mild, unless you have a special preference for the spicy version. By choosing a mild flavoured pizza sauce, you can adjust the flavours as per your wish by adding seasoning and toppings of your choice.


Choose the Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce for Your Homemade Pizza!

Pizza is a dish sought after by many. When baking a pizza for your lovelies at home, you want it to be the best. Pizza sauce is the main ingredient that enhances the flavor of your pizza. As there are various kinds of store-made pizza sauce in the market, you don’t have to take trouble in making the sauce at home. 

Yet, you must carefully choose the best-tasting pizza sauce that intensifies the flavor of your pizza. This guide was prepared to feature the top best store-bought pizzas available in today’s market, their strengths and weaknesses, and frequently asked questions about store-bought pizza sauce. 

Your decision may depend on the style of your pizza, your budget, dietary needs, and most importantly the flavor. This review will guide you through all the available options and help you choose the best store-bought pizza sauce.

About The Author

Scroll to Top